Posted on

ONBOARD DVR FOR FPV QUADCOPTER – HMDVR-S VS. PRODVR

ONBOARD DVR FOR FPV QUADCOPTER – HMDVR-S VS. PRODVR

Onboard DVR is a way to record FPV videos in the best possible quality without all the signal interference from your VTX, by installing a DVR in your mini quad or any RC model really.

Further Reading: How to build a drone for beginners

The Benefits of Having Onboard DVR in a Quadcopter

  • Onboard DVR is a cheap way to capture “high quality” flight videos
  • The DVR records directly from your FPV camera, therefore it won’t be affected by signal interference or image downscale between VTX and VRX
  • No OSD showing in the recorded footage, yet you get to keep the OSD info in your FPV goggles
  • For some people, the video quality might be good enough to replace the heavy HD cameras which can save a lot of weight on the quad for better agility and flight time. This is especially useful for ultralight racing drones and micro drones where you can’t mount a GoPro
ONBOARD DVR FOR FPV QUADCOPTER – HMDVR-S VS. PRODVR
ONBOARD DVR FOR FPV QUADCOPTER – HMDVR-S VS. PRODVR

Click image to enlarge, notice the signal interference in the FPV goggles DVR, and the image detail difference

Here is some test footage to show you the result:

I was using the Foxeer Monster Pro Mini in this test (Buy: Banggood | GetFPVAmazon), just awesome image quality 🙂 You can retire your GoPro now 😀

Onboard DVR vs. Runcam Split?

The Runcam Split is an FPV camera capable of recording HD footage at the same time.

Reviews: Runcam Split, Runcam Split Mini

ONBOARD DVR FOR FPV QUADCOPTER – HMDVR-S VS. PRODVR
ONBOARD DVR FOR FPV QUADCOPTER – HMDVR-S VS. PRODVR

Runcam Split Cameras

Adding an onboard DVR in your quad is actually a similar concept, though there are areas the Split can do better:

  • The Split offers excellent video quality – 1080p at 60fps
  • The Split has more features, for example, camera control via UART, video auto-save at power cut, etc…

But, there are times you might want to consider getting the DVR over the Split:

  • An FPV camera plus a DVR cost much less than the Split – $30 vs. $80
  • Dedicated FPV cameras generally have much lower latency – 20ms vs. 40ms

DVR Options to Install inside a Mini Quad

There are two popular choices which I have tested, I will explain the pro’s and con’s of each one in the rest of this article.

Runcam DVR HMDVR-SEachine ProDVR
BanggoodBanggood
Amazon
 Banggood
Amazon
Size: 3.5g
Weight: 25x25x9mm
Video format: AVI
Resolution: 640×480
Bit Rate: 8Mbps
Size: 5.0g (2.3g)
Weight: 29x22x9mm
Video format: AVI
Resolution: 1280×720
Bit Rate: 16-25Mbps
Size: 9.5g
Weight: 41x33x9mm
Video format: AVI
Resolution: 1280×720, 960×720, 640×480
Bit Rate: 16-25Mbps
ONBOARD DVR FOR FPV QUADCOPTER – HMDVR-S VS. PRODVR
ONBOARD DVR FOR FPV QUADCOPTER – HMDVR-S VS. PRODVR

FPV Onboard DVR Options: HMDVR-S and Eachine ProDVR

HMDVR-S

The HMDVR-S is a lightweight and compact onboard DVR solution, which is perfect for mounting on a quadcopter.

ONBOARD DVR FOR FPV QUADCOPTER – HMDVR-S VS. PRODVR
ONBOARD DVR FOR FPV QUADCOPTER – HMDVR-S VS. PRODVR
ONBOARD DVR FOR FPV QUADCOPTER – HMDVR-S VS. PRODVR
ONBOARD DVR FOR FPV QUADCOPTER – HMDVR-S VS. PRODVR

By removing the case, we can reduce the weight down to only 2.3g! You can probably use it on a Tiny Whoop 🙂 But flight time will be shortened greatly due to its high current draw.

ONBOARD DVR FOR FPV QUADCOPTER – HMDVR-S VS. PRODVR
ONBOARD DVR FOR FPV QUADCOPTER – HMDVR-S VS. PRODVR
ONBOARD DVR FOR FPV QUADCOPTER – HMDVR-S VS. PRODVR
ONBOARD DVR FOR FPV QUADCOPTER – HMDVR-S VS. PRODVR

HMDVR-S Connection & Image Quality

I tried splitting the video signal from the camera and feed it to both the DVR and VTX, and it worked perfectly.

ONBOARD DVR FOR FPV QUADCOPTER – HMDVR-S VS. PRODVR
ONBOARD DVR FOR FPV QUADCOPTER – HMDVR-S VS. PRODVR

DVR Connection to FPV Camera and VTX

Some people suspected that splitting the video signal form the camera might reduce image brightness, or even the image quality overall. But I went back and forth many times and I didn’t notice any difference before and after splitting the signal.

I also tested a few different cameras just to be sure, the results are all the same, no change to image quality and brightness. I tested the Runcam Micro Swift 2, Caddx Micro SDR1 and Foxeer Micro Predator.

ONBOARD DVR FOR FPV QUADCOPTER – HMDVR-S VS. PRODVR
ONBOARD DVR FOR FPV QUADCOPTER – HMDVR-S VS. PRODVR

Issue: Image Cropping

However, there is vertical cropping in the recorded footage with the HMDVR-S. As you can see from the following screenshot, the bottom part of the image is cropped (on the right). I am not sure if this is a generic issue, or just my unit.

ONBOARD DVR FOR FPV QUADCOPTER – HMDVR-S VS. PRODVR
ONBOARD DVR FOR FPV QUADCOPTER – HMDVR-S VS. PRODVR

Connection with Betaflight OSD

Because I am using Betaflight OSD on a flight controller, and I don’t want to have OSD in the recorded video, this is how I connected the DVR, FPV camera, VTX and flight controller. If you want to keep the OSD, you just need to move the V-in of the DVR to the Vout on the FC.

ONBOARD DVR FOR FPV QUADCOPTER – HMDVR-S VS. PRODVR
ONBOARD DVR FOR FPV QUADCOPTER – HMDVR-S VS. PRODVR

Other downsides of the HMDVR-S:

  • When you cut the power, you lose the recording. Therefore make sure you stop the recording before unplugging your battery
  • A new file is created for every 3 mins of recording. and it drops a few frames between files which is noticeable in the playback
  • The current consumption of the HMDVR-S is 250mA which is pretty high, so make sure your 5V BEC is powerful enough to handle it
  • You can’t change any of the DVR settings

Eachine ProDVR

The ProDVR from Eachine is bigger and heavier than the HMDVR-S, it’s clearly designed for ground recording primarily but still feasible to be used on a multirotor.

ONBOARD DVR FOR FPV QUADCOPTER – HMDVR-S VS. PRODVR
ONBOARD DVR FOR FPV QUADCOPTER – HMDVR-S VS. PRODVR

Connection 1 – Video Out to VTX

The ProDVR has video output so you can avoid splitting the video signal from the camera in case that causes any problem.

ONBOARD DVR FOR FPV QUADCOPTER – HMDVR-S VS. PRODVR
ONBOARD DVR FOR FPV QUADCOPTER – HMDVR-S VS. PRODVR

However, that’s a NO GO for FPV, the latency is simply too high at 63ms (excluding latency from FPV camera).

The video output is more useful for ground recording, that’s the only way you can access the DVR’s menu and settings. I actually use this model for my FPV camera testing and here is my test rig 🙂 (I used this to test the Sparrow 2)

ONBOARD DVR FOR FPV QUADCOPTER – HMDVR-S VS. PRODVR
ONBOARD DVR FOR FPV QUADCOPTER – HMDVR-S VS. PRODVR

Connection 2 – Splitting Camera Signal

Luckily, when I split the video signal from the camera to the ProDVR and VTX, I didn’t notice any ill effects to the image brightness or quality at all. So you should be able to connect it this way in your mini quad.

ONBOARD DVR FOR FPV QUADCOPTER – HMDVR-S VS. PRODVR
ONBOARD DVR FOR FPV QUADCOPTER – HMDVR-S VS. PRODVR

Runcam Mini DVR

This is designed to be mounted in a 20x20mm stack. It has user-friendly solder pads and and SD card protector.

ONBOARD DVR FOR FPV QUADCOPTER – HMDVR-S VS. PRODVR
ONBOARD DVR FOR FPV QUADCOPTER – HMDVR-S VS. PRODVR

Although it doesn’t have the image cropping issue but the bit-rate is a bit low on this DVR which affects the image detail a tiny bit. (not very noticeable)

ONBOARD DVR FOR FPV QUADCOPTER – HMDVR-S VS. PRODVR
ONBOARD DVR FOR FPV QUADCOPTER – HMDVR-S VS. PRODVR

Check out my full review of the Runcam Mini DVR module.

Conclusion

There is no perfect DVR at the moment and they all have their pro’s and con’s. I hope manufacturers can come up with a DVR for FPV that addresses all the problems we mentioned.

Right now, the Runcam DVR is my go-to option for a mini quad because of how easy it is to use.

I would have chosen the HMDVR-S, if only it didn’t have the cropping issue. It’s also the smallest, lightest and cheapest on the list. It’s still a good DVR if you don’t mind the cropping.

However, you are unable to change settings on both of these options, and they drop frames between files, which can be bothersome. If these are you concerns, you should consider the ProDVR instead.

For ground recording I would definitely recommend the ProDVR because it has high resolution and bit-rate, you can change settings, and it offers more flexible connection.

Other things you might want to know:

  • The recorded video is 25fps (frame rate per second) when your camera is giving the DVR PAL signal, and it’s 30fps when it’s NTSC (differences between PAL and NTSC). The DVR should ideally detect which video format is used
  • It doesn’t affect brightness or latency when you split the video signal (tested)

View the original article at oscarliang.com

See also  HOW TO CHOOSE ANALOG FPV CAMERA FOR FPV DRONES